Top of Columbus

Columbus / Guides / American
American · Grandview Heights

Third & Hollywood

Birthday celebrations and special occasions.

Closed now $$$ Group FriendlyDate NightCasual Vibes
7.2/10
№ 9 on the List Issue № 137 · 1 wks · Scored by Amina Warsame Full List →
№ 01 · The Brief

Grandview's reliable stage for big nights

Third and Hollywood works because it treats a celebration dinner as a solvable problem: seat the group, keep the kitchen moving, get the ribeye out hot. The menu leans on a short list of proteins done well rather than a sprawl of ideas, and that focus shows in the results. The grilled salmon comes up often as the order for anyone hedging between healthy and indulgent, cooked with enough attention that it doesn't read as an afterthought next to the steaks. The ribeye is the anchor for the occasion crowd, the kind of cut that justifies the upscale pricing and gives the room its supper-club gravity.

Roasted chicken rounds out the trio, a dish that separates a kitchen that can only sear from one that can also work a low, even heat, and it holds its own on a menu built around fire and char. This is a Grandview Heights address, part of the restaurant row along Grandview Avenue, and it draws from both that municipality and the Upper Arlington and Columbus households nearby who want a birthday dinner that doesn't require a reservation gamble. The room runs at real volume on weekends, loud enough that conversation competes with the crowd, which is the tradeoff for a kitchen that turns tables efficiently and a staff that keeps up with large parties without losing track of who ordered what. Service reads as a genuine strength here, the kind of attentiveness that turns a routine Tuesday into something worth marking.

Pricing sits at the upscale tier, appropriate for steak and salmon done at this level, and the room is built for groups and date nights rather than a quiet solo dinner. It is not a room for people who want silence with their ribeye, but for a birthday table of six or eight, it delivers what it promises.

№ 02 · What to Order

The order, from the record

№ 03 · Insider Tip
!

Book ahead for weekend birthdays since the room fills fast and gets loud; the ribeye and salmon are the safest orders for a group with mixed appetites.

Amina Warsame · Top of Columbus
№ 04 · The Verdict

What earns the 7.2

01
Steak and salmon both land

The ribeye and grilled salmon give the kitchen two very different proof points, and both hold up.

02
Built for the occasion table

Service consistently gets singled out for handling birthdays and group nights with real attentiveness.

03
Loud, busy, and worth planning around

Weekend volume is high enough that the room favors groups who want energy over quiet conversation.

The record

Insider Score history

On the List 1 wks Current № 9
How we score

The Insider Score is our own 10-point editorial rating, set by the writer who covers the room. It is never an average of other sites’ stars, and it is never for sale. It weighs three things:

01Track record

How highly a kitchen rates, across how many diners, over how long.

02Consistency

Whether recent diners still agree with the long-term verdict.

03Distinction

What the kitchen does that its category does not.

Third & Hollywood earns a 7.2, great on our scale for American in Columbus.
Amina Warsame
Amina Warsame

Amina Warsame is a Staff Writer at Top of Columbus. Born in Mogadishu and raised in Northland, she grew up between her mother's kitchen and the grocery-cafes of the Somali malls. She writes the guides, sweeps the whole Outerbelt, and covers the Somali and East African tables as the beat she knows best.

More from the List

Nearby on the ranking · Issue № 137

Full List →

Five rooms, every Friday.

The new opening, the sleeper the score just flagged, and the one room worth booking this week. Free.