Westerville does not run on candlelight and tasting menus, but a handful of its everyday rooms hold up for a date night anyway: a quiet corner booth, a shared plate, service that lets you linger. This list leans on rooms in Westerville and neighboring New Albany that work for two, not on decor that was never the point.
№ 01
Delaney's Diner
Westerville $$
Photo via 
Eggs benedict and pancakes anchor the weekend menu at this Westerville diner, though the kitchen's execution swings from plate to plate. It works better for an easy morning conversation than a special occasion, since the coffee and the hash browns have both drawn complaints. Go for the casual, unfussy room, not for consistency.
What to ordereggs benedict, pancakes, hash browns
№ 02
Thai Grille
Westerville $$
Photo via
The tofu curry and pad thai keep couples coming back to this Westerville storefront, where the room stays clean and the staff greets regulars by name. It runs well for a slow dinner and quiet conversation, though the kitchen can lag on ticket times when the tables fill. Order ahead of hunger and settle in.
What to ordertofu curry, pad thai, green curry
№ 03
Bru Burger Bar Westerville
Westerville $$
Photo via
A snack burger and the Baes burger headline the menu at this Westerville burger bar, built for sitting at the bar or a booth over a shared plate. Service quality swings depending on who is working the room, fast and warm on a good night, distracted on a slow one. The room itself reads as comfortable rather than romantic.
What to ordersnack burger, Baes burger, classic burger
№ 04
Koble Grill
Westerville $$
Photo via
A fresh gyro and hand-cut fries move fast at this counter-service Greek spot in Westerville, better suited to a relaxed weeknight dinner than candlelight. Portions run generous enough to split, and the staff keeps the line moving even when the room fills with families. Not a lingering room, but an honest one.
What to orderGyro, Sandwiches, Fries
№ 05
Westerville Grill
Westerville $
Photo via
Meatloaf and diner pie carry the menu at this Westerville institution, decorated with race cars and old photographs that give the room a lived-in, nostalgic pull. It suits a low-key date built on comfort food rather than atmosphere, and the staff treats regulars like family. Takeout runs slower than the posted estimate.
What to ordermeatloaf, burgers, pie
№ 06
Lucky House Chinese Restaurant
Westerville $$
Photo via
Singapore noodle and mapo tofu anchor a menu built for sharing at this Westerville Chinese restaurant, where the dining room stays large, clean, and well kept. Portions run generous enough for two to split several dishes over a long dinner. The staff keeps table service attentive without rushing the meal along.
What to orderSingapore Noodle, spring roll, mapo tofu
№ 07
Great Asian Restaurant
Westerville $$
Photo via
General Tso's chicken and pad thai sit side by side on a menu that spans American-Chinese and Thai kitchens in one Westerville room. The pace favors a quick, affordable dinner over a slow one, with a clean dining room and friendly counter staff. Better for an easy weeknight date than a special occasion.
What to orderpad thai, General Tso's chicken, spring rolls
№ 08
The Original Pancake House
Westerville $$
Photo via
Crepes and eggs benedict lead a deep breakfast menu at this Westerville brunch spot, where servers keep coffee filled and check in without hovering. Parking is easy and the room turns tables fast enough that a weekend wait rarely runs long. Built for a relaxed morning together rather than an evening occasion.
What to ordercrepes, pancakes, eggs benedict
№ 09
Cardinal Pizza
Westerville
Photo via
Pepperoni and banana peppers top the Columbus-style pie at this Westerville pizzeria, which also runs a New York style pizza and a house salad worth sharing. The beer selection and casual room suit a low-key night for two, though phone orders have run past their quoted time. Best enjoyed without a tight schedule.
What to orderpepperoni pizza, Columbus style pizza, house salad
№ 10
Aladdin's New Albany/Westerville
Westerville $$
Photo via
Hummus, falafel, and kebab anchor a Mediterranean menu built for sharing at this New Albany and Westerville room, which runs its own bakery on site. The dining room stays clean and the staff consistent, drawing repeat visits from regulars who know the order. A steady, unfussy choice for a date built around good, fresh food.
What to orderhummus, falafel, kebab
№ 11
Q2 China Bistro
Westerville $$
Photo via
Walnut shrimp and black bean fish fillet headline the menu at this small, nicely appointed Westerville dining room near Polaris Parkway. Portions run generous for the price, and the kitchen handles phone orders as smoothly as table service. The room suits a quiet dinner for two more than a group outing.
What to orderwalnut shrimp, black bean fish fillet, firecracker chicken
№ 12
Brenz Pizza Co New Albany
Westerville $$
Photo via
The Heritage Honey pizza draws consistent praise at this New Albany pizzeria, alongside a straightforward Margherita and pepperoni pie for sharing. The room works for a casual date built around a shared pizza and a slower pace, though the chicken toppings have drawn more mixed notes than the classics. Manage expectations and stick to the basil-forward pies.
What to orderHeritage Honey pizza, Margherita, Pepperoni
Frequently asked
What is the most romantic restaurant near me in Westerville?
It depends on what you want from the evening. Aladdin's and Lucky House both offer generous shared plates and steady service for a slow dinner, while Westerville Grill leans nostalgic and casual. Each entry here carries its own Insider Score, and no restaurant paid to be included.
Are these restaurants actually in Westerville or nearby New Albany?
Most are in Westerville proper. Aladdin's and Brenz Pizza Co listed here operate their New Albany locations, and both are named as such rather than folded into Westerville.
Do any of these restaurants take reservations for a date night?
None of the review notes mention a reservations system, so these read as walk-in rooms. Weekend mornings at brunch spots like The Original Pancake House can bring a short wait.
How is the Insider Score calculated for these picks?
The Insider Score reflects the volume and content of the public review record for each restaurant, weighing consistency and specific dish mentions. It is not a paid placement and no restaurant on this list paid a fee to appear.
ƒ
The data first, then the verdict
We start with the review record, not a press release. Every room here is a real kitchen with a strong rating across a meaningful number of reviews, ranked on our 10-point Insider Score. We weight consistency over time and the rooms locals return to, not the ones tourists pass through once. The list updates as the data does. How we work →
Amina Warsame
Staff Writer · Top of Columbus
Amina Warsame is a Staff Writer at Top of Columbus. Born in Mogadishu and raised in Northland, she grew up between her mother's kitchen and the grocery-cafes of the Somali malls. She writes the guides, sweeps the whole Outerbelt, and covers the Somali and East African tables as the beat she knows best.
