The Best Pizza Spots in Westerville (2026)

Pepperoni pizza here comes loaded and hot, with a sauce that skips the sugary route many competitors take. The lasagna and garlic bread round out a menu built for families rather than trend chasers. Service leans on familiar faces, often family members themselves, and regulars describe a room that has stayed consistent for years. A straightforward pick for a weeknight dinner.

Giammarco's works the Sicilian side of the pizza case: a crisp crust, a well-balanced sauce, and a cheese selection that holds up on carryout orders. The House Favorite pizza, piled with pepperoni, mushrooms, and crumbled sausage, is the order to know. Stromboli and pasta round out a menu built for casual lunches and family takeout runs rather than occasions.

This counter specializes in New York style: a foldable crust under a pepperoni pizza that comes in one size, an extra-large 16 inch pie built for splitting. Delivery runs fast, and the staff steers newcomers toward the right order without fuss. It has become an office lunch standby, priced for groups who want quick, satisfying pizza without ceremony.

The stromboli is the reason to know this name, a large original version that draws praise for hitting the mark every time. The room doubles as a sports bar, with a dining side and a bar side both getting attention from a lean staff during busy stretches. Mozzarella and cheese pizza round out a menu that some regulars call solidly good rather than exceptional.

Minico's has built a following over years of consistent pizza, with servers who know regulars by name and a menu that rarely disappoints on the pie itself. Wings and mushrooms draw more mixed reactions, occasionally landing frozen rather than fresh. The entrance gets crowded at peak times, a sign the room turns steady traffic on reputation alone.

Cardinal Pizza pairs pepperoni and banana peppers on a Columbus-style pie, party-cut and available alongside a New York option, a rare either-or on one menu. The house salad gets specific praise, and the beer selection gives the room a bar feel beyond takeout. Timing on pickup orders can run behind the quoted estimate, so building in slack helps.

Classic Pizza shares its space with a sports bar built around video games and shot-based games, drawing a livelier crowd once night games start. Wings and nachos round out a pizza-forward menu suited to group hangouts rather than quiet dinners. Online ordering runs fast and simple for pickup, though the counter has been known to cut off orders ahead of posted closing time.

The Hoover Bar and Kitchen took over the former Time and Change Restaurant space under new ownership, keeping much of the same menu and room. Pizza sits alongside pasta and sandwiches for a straightforward neighborhood meal. Service has drawn some criticism during short-staffed stretches, but the location and food quality keep regulars returning under the new name.

Brenz Pizza Co sits in New Albany, not Westerville, but its reputation travels the corridor. The Heritage Honey pizza and a well-regarded Margherita anchor a menu built around live-fire pies with a wide range of toppings. Basil and crust quality draw consistent praise, while chicken toppings land as merely adequate. Worth crossing the Outerbelt for if the pull is strong enough.

Gionino's runs from a small storefront with a carryout counter that rewards those who find it. The Meatball Casserole arrives loaded with sauce and cheese, paired well with the house bread, and the Very Veggie stacks toppings generously. The sidewalk approach and modest exterior undersell what is a reliable Westerville option for dine-in or pickup pizza.