Where to Eat the Best Pizza in Powell (2026)

The cheese pizza with half meatball is the order here, built on a crust thin enough to stay light instead of heavy, with a meatball that carries real seasoning. Iacono's has held its spot for a quarter century, and the room still runs as a straightforward family restaurant with enough space for a crowd. Price and service both stay consistent, which is the whole appeal.

This is New American rather than a pizza house, built for groups: reservations get honored, tables for ten get set on time, and the grilled chicken and seasonal vegetables anchor a menu that holds up on repeat visits. The house burger is the other reliable order. Consistency over years, not a single flashy dish, is the case for coming back.

The pizza sub is the standout, a version hard to find elsewhere in the area and good enough to bring people back specifically for it. Chicken tenders and wings round out a casual menu built for families. Order accuracy and wait times on busy nights are the known weak point, so a call ahead to confirm timing is worth it.

Carlucci's Supreme and Deluxe pizzas stand out against the standard party-cut competition around Central Ohio, with a flavor profile that reads as more distinct than most versions of the same pie. The Margherita is the lighter option. It is a neighborhood room with staying power, the kind families return to after years away and find unchanged.

George's runs Columbus-style pizza, thin crust and edge-to-edge toppings, and pepperoni cups up alongside the classics. It draws comparisons to the old-guard party-cut houses across the metro, which is high praise from regulars who have eaten around. Crust chew and spice level run hot for some palates, so a mild pepperoni order is the safer bet on a first visit.

The crust is what people single out at Ange's, holding the whole pizza together with a sauce that leans savory rather than sweet. Wings and salad round out the order, though wing counts on delivery orders have come up short at times. It runs a genuinely warm counter operation, and it works well paired with the sports bar next door.