Grove City runs on pizza houses, and the town supports enough of them to argue about for years. This guide sorts the party-cut regulars from the Greek, Vietnamese and Mexican counters that round out the Broadway corridor and beyond.
№ 01
Blu-Willy’s
Grove City
Photo via 
The bacon jam burger and lemon pepper wings carry this room's reputation, with wings coming out crisp and well coated rather than soggy under sauce. The Reuben stands out too: the sauerkraut reads tossed right into the dressing instead of layered on separately. A casual, group-friendly stop that rewards regulars who keep coming back to the wing sauces.
What to orderbacon jam burger, lemon pepper wings, Reuben sandwich
№ 02
Tacos and Beer | Mexican
Grove City
Photo via
Street tacos and a torta anchor a short menu that moves fast without tasting like a drive-through. The kitchen's quality reads above the Grove City taco average, though the carne asada fries draw complaints about underseasoning even as portions satisfy. Best treated as a quick, reliable order rather than a destination meal.
What to orderstreet tacos, torta, carne asada fries
№ 03
Bowl Boba
Grove City
Photo via
The seafood soup bowl is the order to know here, packed with a mix of seafood in a broth that reviewers single out by name even when they forget what it is called. Boba tea and cold noodle bowls round out a menu built for families and to-go orders alike. Service reads as consistently warm across visits.
What to orderboba tea, seafood soup bowl, cold noodle bowl
№ 04
Grandstand Pizza Shop
Grove City $
Photo via
A downtown Grove City room where the pizza crust draws the most consistent praise, cooked to a texture reviewers call just right. The Italian sub and salad hold up the rest of the menu, and the room itself gets credit for a comfortable, neighborhood feel. Service runs prompt even when the reception on the room is mixed.
What to orderpizza, salad, Italian sub
№ 05
Plum Run Winery
Grove City $$
Photo via
Patio lunch is the move at this winery, where honey chicken tacos and loaded fries get the most consistent praise among the food options. Service can slip at the margins, particularly around paying out at the end of a meal, and the wings and flatbread have drawn complaints about flat seasoning. Best for an easy family lunch outdoors.
What to orderhoney chicken tacos, loaded fries, flatbread
№ 06
Cattleman's Pizza
Grove City $$
Photo via
A long-running neighborhood pizza shop where sides get called out as consistently strong alongside the pizza itself. Staff go out of their way on delivery, and regulars who have moved nearby keep finding new things to order. It settles in as one of the more dependable pizza options in Grove City rather than the flashiest.
What to orderpizza, wings, garlic bread
№ 07
Tammy's Pizza - Hoover at Rt-665
Grove City $$
Photo via
The Hawaiian pizza is the reason this Hoover Road spot on Route 665 has held loyal customers for close to two decades, a version reviewers say resets expectations for the style. That loyalty has frayed recently, though, with sharper complaints about customer service and portion sizes, including extra charges on cheese for the fries. A mixed-record regular.
What to orderHawaiian pizza, cheese fries, pizza
№ 08
Plank's On Broadway
Grove City $
Photo via
Set in an old historic building in Grove City, this pizza and burger room draws a busy crowd that swings between quiet lunches and loud evenings. The cheeseburger holds its own alongside the pizza and wings, and the shop carries a sister-location reputation from the Parsons Avenue original that regulars bring up unprompted. Service holds steady even at volume.
What to orderpizza, cheeseburger, wings
№ 09
Athena's Gyro House
Grove City
Photo via
The lamb gyro is the headline order, built on fresh lamb and a tzatziki sauce reviewers describe as made in house, with fries dusted in paprika as the right side to pair with it. Baklava rounds out the dessert case. The room reads clean and the staff friendly, making this a reliable Greek sandwich stop on the quick end.
What to orderLamb Gyro, Baklava, Fries with Paprika
№ 10
Broadway Plates and Pints
Grove City
Photo via
A neighborhood burger room in Grove City built for date nights and easy dinners, with food arriving fast and hot and a staff that reviewers call attentive across the board. The burger and fries are the standard order, and the room's atmosphere gets singled out as comfortable rather than flashy. Good prices keep it a repeat stop.
What to orderburger, fries, milkshake
№ 11
Flyers Pizza Grove City South/Commercial Point
Grove City $
Photo via
Group orders are this location's strength, with pizzas and giant Italian subs built for birthday parties and family gatherings, and online ordering that lets customers apply coupon codes directly. A single Italian sub also holds up well for a quick solo lunch, arriving hot and fast. Some regulars who transferred loyalty from the Galloway location report a dip in consistency since the move.
What to orderpizza, Italian sub, giant Italian sub
№ 12
Zanzis Pizza Grove City
Grove City $
Photo via
A small, owner-run pizza spot in Grove City where the specialty and cheese pizzas draw praise alongside a staff reviewers describe as laid-back and welcoming. Service and timing can slip though, with at least one report of a pizza running well past its promised time with no explanation offered up front. Worth the plaza parking lot when the kitchen is on schedule.
What to ordercheese pizza, pepperoni pizza, specialty pizza
Frequently asked
What is the best pizza restaurant in Grove City?
Grove City supports more pizza shops than most towns its size, and this guide ranks them by an Insider Score built from the public review record, not by any payment from the restaurants. Cattleman's Pizza, Grandstand Pizza Shop and Tammy's Pizza all draw strong, specific praise for their crust and sides, so the right pick depends on whether a diner wants a sit-down room or a quick carryout order.
Where can I find good pizza restaurants near me in Grove City?
Grove City's pizza houses cluster along Broadway and Hoover Road, from Grandstand Pizza Shop downtown to Tammy's Pizza on Route 665 and Flyers Pizza toward Commercial Point. None of the restaurants in this guide paid for placement; ranking comes from an Insider Score built off the public review record for each spot.
What is the best Greek restaurant in Grove City?
Athena's Gyro House is the clear Greek pick in Grove City, built on a lamb gyro that draws consistent praise for its lamb quality and house tzatziki, plus baklava and paprika fries as strong sides. Its Insider Score reflects the public review record only; no restaurant in this guide paid to be listed.
Is there good Vietnamese food in Grove City?
Bowl Boba covers the Vietnamese lane in Grove City, with a seafood soup bowl and cold noodle bowl that reviewers return to regularly alongside its boba tea program. Its placement here comes from its Insider Score, calculated from the public review record, and no restaurant pays to appear in this guide.
ƒ
The data first, then the verdict
We start with the review record, not a press release. Every room here is a real kitchen with a strong rating across a meaningful number of reviews, ranked on our 10-point Insider Score. We weight consistency over time and the rooms locals return to, not the ones tourists pass through once. The list updates as the data does. How we work →
Amina Warsame
Staff Writer · Top of Columbus
Amina Warsame is a Staff Writer at Top of Columbus. Born in Mogadishu and raised in Northland, she grew up between her mother's kitchen and the grocery-cafes of the Somali malls. She writes the guides, sweeps the whole Outerbelt, and covers the Somali and East African tables as the beat she knows best.
