Where to Eat the Best Pizza in Gahanna (2026)

Gatsby's runs as a neighborhood bar first, pizza kitchen second, and that order works in its favor. The room hosts reunions and regulars who have watched it stay steady for decades. Pizza is the reason people keep coming back, but the draw is just as much the bar itself and the crowd it holds on a Saturday night.

Pizza Nerds operates delivery and carryout only, and the thin crust is the standout: crisp on the outside, soft inside, a harder combination to pull off than it sounds. The Thick Crust Mario with hot honey has built its own following. Order accuracy and customer service after a mistake have drawn complaints, so confirm the order before hanging up.

Bellacino's sits in a strip mall and keeps the format tight: stromboli, grinders, wings, pizza, all handled at counter-service pace. The toasted grinder bread gets singled out for its crunch-to-soft ratio, and the wings pull as much praise as the pizza does. Service runs fast and the room stays clean, built for a quick family dinner more than a night out.

Sexton's operates out of the Gahanna food hall, where counter service and easy parking make it a practical stop rather than a destination sit-down. Cheese, pepperoni, and specialty pies come out generously topped, enough that the grease has been noted as a hazard to clothing. Staff enthusiasm at the counter gets called out as part of the experience.

Gahanna Pizza Plus has built its reputation on consistency, the kind that keeps offices ordering for group lunches and families ordering on stormy weeknights. Subs get nearly as much credit as the pizza does. Pies arrive hot even on large orders, and the current ownership, a longtime employee who bought the shop, has kept the quality where regulars expect it.

Tony & Enzo's runs counter service with a pleasant front staff, and the cheese pizza and boneless wings get the most consistent praise. The deep dish draws a split verdict: some find it bread-heavy with toppings that slide rather than melt in. It lands as a decent quick option, not a lock for best in Gahanna.